a7d846aa33
Capture the walk-with-me + qfd session: CONTEXT.md ubiquitous-language glossary, DESIGN.md goal-driven cascade (Beauty / Pride & Peace / public voice), and ADRs for Note identity (Path) and the two reference modes (Live vs Snapshot).
21 lines
2.1 KiB
Markdown
21 lines
2.1 KiB
Markdown
---
|
|
status: accepted (refines ADR-0001)
|
|
---
|
|
|
|
# Two reference modes: Live (Path) and Snapshot (SHA)
|
|
|
|
A reference to a Note resolves in one of two deliberate modes. A **Live reference** (by **Path**) resolves to the Note's *current* content — this is a Backlink you follow in your own repo, and it reflects edits (Note identity = Path, per ADR-0001). A **Snapshot reference** (by **SHA**) resolves to that *exact, immutable* version — this is a shared or bookmarked stack link (`?stackedNotes=sha`), content-addressed so what was shared cannot change underneath a reader.
|
|
|
|
This refines ADR-0001, which framed SHA-keyed references as "a fragility." That framing was too absolute: SHA-pinning is the **correct** tool for a Snapshot reference. Pinning is an *integrity* feature — it guarantees a shared view can't be silently rewritten, so no reader is misled and no author is misrepresented.
|
|
|
|
## Considered options
|
|
|
|
- **Two explicit modes (chosen).** Live=Path, Snapshot=SHA, each with a clear purpose. Cost: the resolver must support both, and the UI must make the mode legible (you should know whether you're reading "now" or "as shared").
|
|
- **Single mode, Path only (rejected).** Simpler, but a shared link would always re-resolve to current content — destroying the integrity guarantee that makes sharing safe.
|
|
- **Single mode, SHA only (rejected by ADR-0001).** In-repo navigation would break on every edit.
|
|
|
|
## Consequences
|
|
|
|
- The system **pre-caches** aggressively (content is cached by both SHA and Path on every fetch / freshness pull) so the pinned version is usually present, including offline.
|
|
- When a Snapshot reference's pinned content is genuinely unavailable (never-fetched + offline — common on a flaky mobile connection), the system **falls back to the most up-to-date cached version and shows a banner** disclosing "this is the latest available, not the exact shared version." Integrity is preserved by **disclosure, not refusal**: the reader is never silently shown different content, but is also never dead-ended on the metro. (This chooses graceful continuity over a hard "unavailable" stop, given mobile is the primary read context.)
|